Miami, a vibrant yet contradictory city, where one would expect diversity to flourish in every corner, faces an unsettling paradox for nonprofit organizations working in the realm of the classical performing arts, such as opera, zarzuela, and ballet. While some of us witness the growing need for quality cultural experiences, we also know that small and mid-sized artistic organizations—particularly those dedicated to opera, ballet, and classical music—face nearly insurmountable obstacles in sustaining their mission to bring these disciplines to the community. The challenge does not lie in the passion of the artists or the talent of the creators, but in an opaque system that stifles these organizations and the performing arts from their foundation: the theaters and their peculiarities, right here in Miami-Dade County.
For over 12 years, The Opera Atelier has passionately promoted the art of opera and music education in Miami. We have done so through our seasons, educational programs, and social initiatives, with the support of prominent cultural institutions like the Miami-Dade Department of Cultural Affairs, The Children Trust, and the Florida Department of State Division of Arts and Culture, among others. Despite this recognition, it is a harsh reality that much of the hard-earned resources for our artistic projects are directed toward paying for theater rentals or performance venues that, rather than being allies of the arts, have become operational and financial obstacles. Adding to this reality are the high costs associated with promotion and outreach, especially on social media and through marketing firms that promise to attract new audiences to performances. However, their real impact often falls short. Instead of generating significant audiences, these initiatives and pretentious arts and culture directories often amount to little more than sending a few (often annoying) emails for exorbitant fees, posting instant ads, counting impressions, likes, and other metrics—all while covering their own pockets in the dizzying promotional frenzy of the so-called modern "arts ecosystem."
The performance spaces available in Miami and its surroundings are not only excessively expensive but also suffer from numerous deficiencies. These range from inadequate lighting equipment, the absence of fly systems, orchestra pits, and acoustic issues to poor cleanliness, insufficient technical support, lack of box office systems, and inadequate safety measures, among countless other shortcomings. Adding to this, these venues are often staffed by personnel lacking the professionalism and expertise required for theatrical productions. In short, the basic services a theater must provide to ensure the proper production of performances are, at best, mediocre or nonexistent. These shortcomings affect both the artists and the audience, consistently compromising the theatrical experience.
A particularly painful example occurred during one of our recent productions. Despite renting and paying for a theater, this particular venue left Christmas decorations that bordered and covered the stage. To our astonishment, these decorations remained during the performance, distorting and altering the scenery of the work. This incident not only illustrates a profound lack of respect for the nature of the performing arts but also constitutes an affront to artistic integrity. On prior occasions at this same theater, we overlooked the fact that its organizational logo is permanently affixed to both sides of the stage backdrop, regardless of the event being presented. This represents not only an aesthetic imposition on the organizations renting the theater but could also confuse audiences regarding the authorship of the productions. Photos and videos used for historical archives or promotion retain these logos, misrepresenting ownership. While we have reluctantly accepted this branding imposition due to the significant difficulty in finding available and suitable theaters in Miami, the recent holiday décor incident surpasses all imaginable limits.
Do not misunderstand me; I deeply appreciate and enjoy the Christmas season, but I believe such decorations belong on the streets, in parks, parades, shopping centers, or even my living room tree—not in the sacred space of a stage. Allowing Christmas garlands and lights on a stage rented for an opera production, without those decorations being part of the show, is as absurd as renting a furnished house with permanently attached unattractive paintings, leaving the tenant unable to express their identity. The stage should serve as a neutral canvas for the artistic production renting the theater, not a permanent advertising space for the venue’s management or ownership.
In the past, theaters were built as temples of art, designed not only to host performances but to act as cultural hubs where communities gathered and celebrated human creativity. These spaces reflected a societal commitment to culture and knowledge, supported by patrons, governments, and communities that understood the intrinsic value of art. In contrast, the performance spaces in our city today seem driven predominantly by a commercial approach that prioritizes profitability over artistic collaboration. The result is a system that often deprives artists of the theatrical tools necessary to shine, limiting opportunities for performers and reducing public access to opera, ballet, and classical music. Consequently, ticket prices are increasingly becoming prohibitively expensive. Today, it is not uncommon to find individual tickets priced in the hundreds of dollars for opera, ballet, or a prestigious classical music series concert—the equivalent of what an average family might pay annually for home internet access.
This discouraging landscape disproportionately affects the most vulnerable and financially disadvantaged: the artists and the nonprofit organizations working in the performing arts. These organizations strive to enrich the artistic and cultural fabric of the city but find their financial resources, often in the form of grants from public and private institutions, increasingly constrained. For example, in one well-known Miami-Dade city, our organization received a $6,000 grant to present several events. However, renting a single substandard venue in that city for one performance could consume nearly 40% of that grant, not including additional rehearsal costs. This highlights how rental expenses alone severely limit project feasibility for local artists.
High rental costs for both performances and rehearsals, often preventing the possibility of rehearsing on the actual performance stage, compel artists to sacrifice dress rehearsals or conduct them on the same day as the event. This leads to artist exhaustion, as they must rehearse and perform on the same day. Additionally, budgets for promotion consume a large portion of resources, preventing organizations from prioritizing payments to the lifeblood of the arts: the artists. Theaters, for their part, require full rental fees and insurance to even open their doors. As a result, we often find ourselves working without fair compensation, turning artistic and technical efforts into a perpetual "in-kind" contribution—or as I’ve said before, "all for the love of art."
This reality is ironic and deeply lamentable. Without artists, there is no art; and without genuine support or adequate theater infrastructure, the performing arts are left in an extremely vulnerable state. A stage without artists loses its meaning, becoming a space for boxing rings, tedious conferences, storage for props and dirty backdrops, or even, at best, an improvised movie hall. This scenario limits the possibility of presenting full-scale productions of operas or ballets to large companies with substantial budgets. These are the only entities capable of accessing state-of-the-art theaters, which possess the necessary technical conditions for these demanding art forms. As a result, such genres are increasingly reserved for economically privileged audiences and world-renowned artists who do not share the local community's struggles.
The situation has worsened this year due to recent policy decisions, including alarming delays in cultural grants, vetoes of arts funding in Florida, and reductions in Miami-Dade budgets. These political and administrative actions further undermine the capacity of arts organizations to fulfill their missions. Meanwhile, large, well-established companies, often resident in excellent, modern theaters, enjoy resources and conditions that seem unattainable for emerging artistic organizations. Ticket prices for these grand spectacles remain unaffordable for low- or middle-income communities, limiting general access and reserving such events for an elite sector.
At The Opera Atelier, we have taken the opposite approach: offering affordable, even free, tickets to address the globally recognized audience crisis in opera and classical music. Our commitment to innovative productions, fresh reinterpretations, and a focus on musical purity has earned praise from critics and connoisseurs. Yet, even with these virtues, we face a system that would seem not to favor those striving to balance inequalities. This situation jeopardizes not only our organization but also the future of alternative initiatives in opera, ballet, zarzuela, and classical music in Miami.
If theater administrators and managers become more receptive to artistic collaboration and public policies genuinely support the profound value of art in our community, organizations like ours—and opera as a medium for local artists—could thrive. However, it remains to be seen if this will happen. Art is resilient. Artists have shown time and again that their talent prevails even in the most adverse conditions.
Today, The Opera Atelier raises its voice not just for us but for everyone who believes in the transformative power of opera and classical music. This article is a call to action for theater directors and owners to become true allies of the arts and for authorities to revise their course. Without genuine access to art, a community loses its soul; and without artists, humanity’s essence fades away. The need for art to strengthen the human spirit transcends the mere supply and demand of entertainment, which only seeks to alleviate the tedium of life with fleeting distractions.
Fortunately, and as a final note on the state of theaters and performance spaces: miracles still happen for us!
Comments